Several readers mentioned that their selection also had enough action for most guys to really enjoy it. I marked those with ***

A number of titles were recommend by a handful of people. I marked those with ++ 

Return to Me ++

Message In a Bottle ++

English Patient ***

Ladyhawke

A Knight's Tale ***

Pretty Woman ++

Moonstruck

Far and Away

Love Story

City of Angels ++

The Cutting Edge

Somewhere in Time ++

Regarding Henry ++

Ghost ++

Untamed Heart ++

A Walk to Remember ++

You've Got Mail ++

Tortilla Soup

Witness

Annie Hall

The American President

The Princess Bride ++ ***

Untamed Heart ++

Ever After ++

The African Queen

What Dreams May Come ++

Jerry McGuire ***

A Walk in the Clouds ++

Barefoot in the Park

I Don't Buy Kisses Anymore

Kate & Leopold ++

Pearl Harbor ***

The Wedding Planner

Serendipity ++

An Affair to Remember

Sleepless in Seattle ++

When Harry Met Sally ++

Titanic

Dr. Zhivago

Shrek

You've Got Mail ++

The Bridges Over Madison County

Notting Hill

Il Postino

Harold & Maude (probably only for those who enjoy "art" films)

Never Been Kissed

Music from Another Room

The Saint ***

Bed of Roses ++

The Mirror Has Two Faces

Anne of Green Gables
Anne of Avonlea
Father Goose
The Sound of Music
Little Women
Top Gun ***
Sabrina
I.Q.
Joe Versus the Volcano
Fools Rush In ++
French Kiss
Runaway Bride
Always
Forever Young
Breakfast at Tiffany's
Casablanca ++
Fiddler on the Roof
Dances with Wolves
Phenomenon
Beauty and the Beast
The Cutting Edge
Emma
Room With a View
First Knight
Gone With the Wind
Groundhog Day
Roxanne
Dream a Little Dream
Can't Buy Me Love
It Could Happen To You
La Bamba
Romancing the Stone ***
Last of the Mohicans ***
The Scarlet Pimpernel
Pretty in Pink
Shadowlands
The Mask of Zorro ***
Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves ***
Sense and Sensibility
Up Close and Personnel
The Wedding Singer
She's All That
While You Were Sleeping
Father of the Bride
The Three Musketeers ***

Love Affair

At First Sight

As Good As It Gets

Pillow Talk

Pay It Forward

Life Is Beautiful

Green Card

Truly, Madly, Deeply

Moulin Rouge ++

Sweet November ++

Like Water for Chocolate ++

Mystic Pizza

Dirty Dancing

Romeo & Juliet

Hope Floats

Sea of Love

Now Voyager

Only You ++

Family Man

Where the Heart Is

The Sure Thing

One Fine Day

Amelie

Always

Somersby

Say Anything

Don Juan DeMarco

Moonstruck

I Am Sam

St. Ives

Office and a Gentleman

Love & Basketball

The Fisher King

Down to You

Patch Adams